Ultimate magazine theme for WordPress.

Organ Donation: Bundestag Rejects ‘Dissent Solution’

After an emotional debate about organ donation, the Berlin Bundestag in the German capital dismissed the so-called ‘dissent solution’ Health Minister Jens Spahn had supported. The ‘consent solution’ won.

“There is no right or wrong”, Germany’s Health Minister Jens Spahn told the Bundestag during a thorough discussion about organ donation. But in the late morning, a majority of MPs rejected his approach, in spite of the fact that a majority of all Germans supports it.

Online Register to be Established

Spahn’s ‘dissent solution’ would have meant that all Germans would have been organ donors automatically. In the case of death, their organs could have been used for patients who needed them. In order to avoid becoming an organ donor, patients would have been forced to dissent in writing beforehand.

The supporters of that solution were hoping to increase the number of needed organs that way. On the other hand, MPs who supported the ‘consent solution’ also favored changes to existing regulations. In future, an online register will show doctors or hospitals who agreed to organ donation during their lifetime and who did not.

This solution also forces the administrative offices all over Germany to ask all citizens whether they want to be organ donors after they die. The question will be asked every ten years. Opponents of this approach cited the additional administrative effort as a reason against the ‘consent solution’.

‘Good Debate’

For several months, the entire country had discussed the organ donation matter before the Berlin Bundestag decided today. The caucuses allowed a free vote. Health Minister Spahn said after the parliament’s decision, this had not been about winning or losing. Even though he had been convinced the other solution would have achieved more, Spahn said he accepted the vote.

Germany’s Health Minister Jens Spahn did not get his way.

The minister thanked his colleagues for a “good debate” and stated the discussion in all of Germany had been positive too. Spahn promised he would do everything he could to make the solution the Bundestag voted for a success.

In 2019, more than 900 people in Germany donated organs. Some supporters of the ‘consent solution’ claimed the ‘dissent’ approach would not have increased that number substantially anyway, as data from European countries other than Germany had shown. One of the proponents of the ‘consent solution’ was Annalena Baerbock, one of the leaders of the German Greens.

In a recent poll commissioned by the TV channel ZDF, 61 percent of all Germans would have chosen Minister Spahn’s ‘dissent solution’. The Bundestag, on the other hand, wanted more self-determination for the citizens in regard to organ donation.

By the way: The publication you are reading, The Berlin Spectator, was established in January of 2019. We have worked a whole lot, as you can see. But there has hardly been any income. This is something we urgently need to change. Would you consider contributing? We would be very thankful. Our donations page can be found here.