Five years ago, the Islamist Anis Amri murdered twelve people, in a terror attack at one of Berlin’s main Christmas markets. Before and after the crime, the German authorities kept on failing.
Berlin, December 19th, 2019. Update: December 19th, 2021 (The Berlin Spectator) — In 2014, Nada Cizmar from Czechia left her son and husband in Dresden and moved to Berlin. Whether she would have returned to her family later is a question that will never be answered because she was murdered when she visited the Christmas market at ‘Breitscheidplatz’ square on the day of the terror attack, December 19th, 2016.
She was 34 years old when she was run over by a huge truck stolen and driven by the Islamist terrorist Anis Amri, who should not have had the opportunity to murder anyone on that day, because the authorities could have known he was a threat, a living time bomb, had they done their homework. But warnings were ignored.
The other victims were Anna and Georgiy Bagratuni, Sebastian Berlin, Fabrizia Di Lorenzo, Dalia Elyakim, Christoph Herrlich, Klaus Jacob, Angelika Klösters, Dorit Krebs, Peter Völker and Lukasz Urban. Urban, a Polish citizen, was the official driver of the truck. Amri shot him before the attack. The other casualties were Christmas market visitors from Germany, Ukraine, Israel and Italy.
Pattern of Failures
It was not the first time the authorities failed in connection with a terror attack in Germany. There is a pattern. These are some cases:
- In September of 1972, Palestinian terrorists of the organization Black September murdered twelve members of the Israeli Olympic team in Munich. Had the police not made grave mistakes, part of the bloodbath might have been prevented.
- In 1977, when Hanns Martin Schleyer, the President of the Employer Association, was taken hostage by members of the extremist left-wing ‘Red Army Faction’, the West German authorities could have found and possibly freed him, had they not messed up their own communication.
- The German authorities failed completely when the radical right-wing terror group NSU murdered immigrants and one police officer between 2000 and 2007. Missing documents and other issues led to an investigation chaos.
- Before the terror attacks in New York City and Arlington (Virginia) on September 11th, 2001, the authorities failed to identify and stop the ‘Hamburg cell’ which included Mohammed Atta, one of the ringleaders of the worst Islamist terrorist attacks of all time.
There have also been cases in which the German authorities successfully ended terrorist activity or thwarted attacks. For instance, they freed all hostages from a Lufthansa jet hijacked by Palestinian terrorists in 1977, except its pilot Jürgen Schumann. He was murdered on the aircraft before the elite police unit GSG9 could become active.
Communication with Islamic State
At the Christmas market at ‘Breitscheidplatz’ in Berlin, as many as 55 people were injured in Amri’s attack. Some of them still need care today, five years after the crime. One more victim, Sascha Hüsges, who was hurt badly when he tried to help others escape the truck on that terrible day, died as a result of his injuries nearly five years later, on October 26th, 2021.
What police officers and other helpers saw at the scene on December 19th, 2016, led to traumas. Ninety-two individuals needed to be treated. On the day of the attack, Anis Amei approached the truck at a parking lot and shot the driver. Then he drove the heavy vehicle to ‘Breitscheidplatz’ where he circled the crowded Christmas market several times while he was communicating with his friends from the Islamic State. Then he drove the truck straight into the crowd on the market.
He destroyed several stalls and ran over the victims. The only reason Amri did not murder many more people is a security system the truck was equipped with. Because of the collision with those stalls, an automatic brake was applied. The Swedish-made Scania truck could not be moved anymore.
Wrong Implications Drawn
Anis Amri fled the scene. At 8:02 p.m., the first call reached Berlin’s police department. Soon, a suspect was arrested but released again because he had nothing to do with the terror act. In the meantime, Anis Amri left Germany and went to Italy via the Netherlands and France.
Soon it turned out the Moroccan intelligence had warned the German authorities about Amri, months before the murders. They told both the Federal Intelligence Service and the Federal Police Office that Amri was in contact with the Islamic State. On top of it all, the public learned the German authorities had actually observed him for a while.
But those in charge came to the conclusion he was just a criminal who was in the process of turning away from jihadism. That is why they refrained from arresting him. Data extracted from Amri’s phone showed he went to that same Christmas market several times before he launched his terror attack. And he spoke to an Islamic State contact more than once.
On the day after the attack, the German police asked witnesses for help, once they had noticed they had arrested the wrong man. For far too long, police assumed they had the right guy. This aspect had ramifications and did not exactly help the investigation. The authorities could have found out a lot more during the first hours after the crime.
They did not follow their own guidelines for cases like this terror attack when they assumed the culprit was behind bars. Maybe the authorities should have questioned known Islamists in the city in order to extract information about Amri. And the investigation on site was not conducted the way it should have been.
A suspension of deportation document that contained the terrorist’s name was found in the truck he used as a weapon, a day after the attack. By that time, Amri had already left the country. In spite of the document they finally had found, the German authorities said it did not prove Amri had anything to do with the bloodbath at the Christmas market, which is one of the weirdest aspects of them all.
Memorial at Christmas Market
It took until December 21st, 2016. On that day, the investigators understood who was responsible. They placed a high bounty on Amri’s head. On December 23rd, Anis Amri was shot dead by Italian police after he had opened fire on them when he was stopped in Sesto San Giovanni near Milan.
Three weeks after the terror attack, Germany’s Minister of Justice Heiko Maas, who became Foreign Minister later, admitted mistakes had been made. A special investigator commissioned by the Berlin Senate came up with a report in late 2017, in which he listed several failures. A board of inquiry by the Berlin Bundestag looked into the matter. In June of this year, it came up with a 1,873-page report. The board came to the conclusion that misjudgement and other failures kept the authorities from stopping Amri before the terror attack.
Memorial on Site
In the first years after the attack, before Corona hit, the same Christmas market at Breitscheidplatz in Berlin’s Charlottenburg borough was crowded. Most visitors did not even notice the small memorial for the victims, located on the stairs in front of Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church. People were in Christmas mode, drinking hot wine punch and walking across the market with all its lights and stalls. In 2020, there was no Christmas market due to the Corona pandemic. This year, it is back, in spite of even higher infection numbers.
Around the Christmas market, anti-terror bollards are supposed to prevent another attack of this kind from happening there. But what about all other crowded places in Berlin?
Features about Berlin’s Christmas markets (2021):